Asking Neutrons where they have been – Past of a quantum particle

May 10, 2018 5:11 pm Published by

‘‘What was the past of a photon which went through an interferometer ?’’, this question is the central point in the world from Lev Vaidman and his co-workers published in 1. In this particular paper Danan et al. use use a Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) tuned such that theoutputs interfere constructively, ensuring that all photons exit the second beam splitter in the same direction. The authors probe where the photons were in two situations: i)  interference measurement and ii) when there is a which-way measurement. The which-way marking is achieved by vibrating mirrors at unique frequencies. The applied setup, together with the obtained power spectrum, is illustrated below on the right side. The authors suggest  in their paper discontinues trajectories of the photons and argue that this can be intuitively understood: one should consider not just the possible paths of the photons traveling forwards through the system but also the paths that a photon traveling backwards from the detector. However, their experiment was carried out with a classical laser beam and their results can be fully explained within the framework of Maxwell theory. To test the statement of Danan et al. an experiment of pure quantum nature is called for, which we have done in our neutron interferometric experiment which is schematically illustrated below on the right side. Our new results are mow presented  in the journal “Physical Review A2.


Our  experiment clearly confirms that standard quantum mechanics does provide an intuitive picture as well as a correct quantitative argument of the observed phenomena in the three-beam interferometer. Refuting the claim of Danan et al. that by the use of the two-state vector formulation a more intuitive understanding can be gained. Furthermore, in studying the interference effect, particularly in a destructive case, the occurrence of zero intensity is explained. This situation is interpreted in a mistaken manner as non-continuous trajectories in the paper of Danan et al. Our results witness the multifold presence of the neutron’s wave function in the interferometer. See here for a more detailed explanation and experimental details of our latest work. A photography of the applied setup is depicted below


1. A. Danan, D. Farfurnik, S. Bar-Ad, and L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 240402 (2013). ↩

2. Hermann Geppert-Kleinrath, Tobias Denkmayr, Stephan Sponar, Hartmut Lemmel, Tobias Jenke, and Yuji Hasegawa, Phys. Rev. A  97, 052111 (2018). ↩